A Wispr Flow alternative for lawyers

Josef LongOctober 17, 20266 min readGeneral information, not legal advice

Wispr Flow is a popular dictation app, and it is fast. If you are a lawyer, the question to ask of any dictation tool is not how accurate it is. It is where your words go while they are being turned into text. This page lays out what Wispr Flow says about that, what to ask any vendor, and how dictation that runs on your own computer differs.

What Wispr Flow says it does

Wispr describes its app in its own published policies. Two points matter for a law firm:

WisprData usage policy Wispr Consumer Data Usage Policy The vendor's own description of what happens to audio and text when the app is used. Read at wispr.ai Wispr Flow docsSecurity Data Security and Encryption How the vendor says audio is protected in transit and at rest, and how Privacy Mode works. Read at docs.wisprflow.ai

Why that matters for privileged work

A lawyer's duty of confidentiality covers client information, whatever tool carries it. Sending audio of a client matter to a third party's servers is a disclosure decision. Many firms will decide it is acceptable under a strong contract, and some matters may need the client's consent first. The ABA's Formal Opinion 512 (July 29, 2024) discusses these questions for generative AI tools. Read the opinion. There is a plain-English version in Can lawyers use ChatGPT with client information?

How local dictation differs

QuestionCloud dictation (Wispr Flow, per its published policy)Local dictation (VaultScribe design)
Where speech becomes textOn the vendor's servers.On your own computer.
What is keptGoverned by the vendor's settings and terms, such as Privacy Mode.Audio is held briefly in memory, discarded after transcription, and not written to disk.
How you checkRead the policy and the contract.Block the network with your own firewall and dictate.
Legal featuresGeneral-purpose writing tool.Per-matter word lists, polish with a check that numbers, dates and names are unchanged, approved clauses by voice, and time entries drafted for your approval.

The full description is on Private dictation for lawyers.

When Wispr Flow is a reasonable choice

For non-confidential writing, such as marketing copy, personal notes or internal memos with no client information, a cloud dictation app can be a good fit. The point of this page is not that cloud dictation is wrong. It is that the choice should be made on purpose, matter by matter, rather than by whatever is installed on a lawyer's laptop.

Six questions to ask any dictation vendor

  1. Is the audio sent to your servers? If so, to which providers, and under what contract?
  2. What do you retain, and for how long? Ask about audio, text and any screen or context data the app reads.
  3. Is any of it used to train models? Ask whether the default is opt-in or opt-out.
  4. What does the app read from my screen? Some tools use surrounding text to improve output.
  5. Can it be limited by matter or by app? Lawyers need to keep one client's terms away from another.
  6. Can I check the claims myself? A vendor that is confident will welcome a firewall test.

Questions

Is Wispr Flow safe for client information?

That depends on your obligations and its current terms. Its published policy says audio is sent to its servers for processing, and it describes a Privacy Mode that limits retention. For privileged material, read the terms and decide whether that disclosure is acceptable, which may include client consent.

Is there a dictation tool that works without sending audio to the cloud?

Yes. Local dictation runs the speech model on your own computer. VaultScribe is designed this way.

Can I use VaultScribe today?

No. It is a design preview and is accepting founding design partners. It is not available to buy or download.

Where VaultScribe fits

VaultScribe is a private AI workspace for law firms, and dictation is one part of it. I am looking for founding design partners, with a non-binding letter of intent and terms agreed on a call.

Become a design partner See how dictation works

Wispr Flow is a trademark of its owner. VaultScribe is not affiliated with or endorsed by Wispr. This page quotes the vendor's published policies, which may change, and is not a review of the product. General information, not legal advice.